Additional information
| Author | Geneen Roth |
|---|
Feeding the Hungry Heart
By Geneen Roth (1982)
What the internet says
Aggregated insights from reviews and discussions across the web.
Overall reception: Mostly positive
Feeding the Hungry Heart by Geneen Roth is generally well-received as a pioneering work in emotional eating and intuitive eating, with a Goodreads rating of 4.0 stars from 908 ratings and strong positive sentiment across platforms. Readers consistently praise Roth's compassionate, non-diet approach that treats compulsive eating as a symptom of deeper emotional issues rather than a willpower problem. The book's unique format—combining Roth's insights with personal stories from workshop participants—resonates with many who feel understood for the first time in their struggles with food and body image.
However, the reception is somewhat mixed due to the book's structure and scope. Multiple reviewers note that the collection of short stories from different contributors creates a 'hodge podge' feel with varying writing styles, which some find less cohesive than Roth's solo-authored works. The book appears most impactful for those dealing with binge eating and emotional overeating, while readers with different eating disorder patterns report feeling less connection to the material. Despite being published over 40 years ago, many readers find the core message about self-acceptance and listening to body wisdom remains relevant, though some wish for more concrete guidance beyond the philosophical framework.
What readers loved
- Compassionate, non-judgmental approach that helps readers feel understood rather than shamed about compulsive eating
- Pioneering philosophy that food obsession stems from emotional hunger, not lack of willpower, offering hope that change is possible without dieting
- Real-life stories from workshop participants provide relatable experiences that validate readers' struggles
- Core message about intuitive eating and self-acceptance remains relevant decades after publication
- Helpful for distinguishing between physical hunger and emotional hunger, promoting awareness and presence
- Provides self-esteem building mantras and wisdom that readers return to when feeling out of control
- Particularly effective for those trapped in binge-diet cycles who need permission to trust their bodies
Common critiques
- Hodge-podge structure with mixed fiction, poetry, and stories from multiple contributors creates inconsistent writing quality and flow
- More philosophical than practical—lacks concrete step-by-step guidance or specific eating guidelines some readers seek
- May not resonate with readers whose eating issues are primarily biological rather than emotional
- Some readers with different eating disorder patterns (not binge eating) found limited applicability to their situations
- Can increase anxiety about eating and weight gain for some readers rather than providing relief
Reviews
There are no reviews yet.