Additional information
| Author | Joanne Schwartz |
|---|
Town Is by the Sea
By Joanne Schwartz (2017)
What the internet says
Aggregated insights from reviews and discussions across the web.
Overall reception: Mostly positive
Town Is by the Sea by Joanne Schwartz, illustrated by Sydney Smith, is widely praised as a beautifully crafted picture book that explores the life of a coal miner's son in 1950s Cape Breton. Professional reviews from School Library Journal, Kirkus, and Quill and Quire consistently highlight the book's stunning watercolor illustrations and understated, poetic text. The book has received numerous accolades and strong ratings on Goodreads (average 4.19 stars from nearly 1,800 ratings). Reviewers frequently note the powerful contrast between the bright, sun-filled scenes of the boy's daily life above ground and the dark, claustrophobic images of his father working in the coal mines beneath the sea.
The reception reveals a notable divide between adult and child readers. Adult reviewers, particularly parents and librarians, find the book deeply moving and appreciate its subtle exploration of class, labor, and inherited destiny. Many describe feeling emotional about the boy's matter-of-fact acceptance that he will follow his father into the mines. However, several reviewers note that children seem less affected by the darker themes, focusing instead on the boy's freedom to walk alone to the store. Some readers express confusion about the time period, as the illustrations don't clearly signal the 1950s setting until the author's note at the end. Despite minor criticisms about the text being somewhat understated, the book is overwhelmingly regarded as a significant artistic achievement that pairs exceptional illustrations with meaningful social commentary.
What readers loved
- Sydney Smith's watercolor illustrations are consistently described as stunning, gorgeous, and award-worthy, with particular praise for his use of light on water
- Powerful visual contrast between bright, spacious scenes above ground and dark, claustrophobic coal mining scenes creates emotional impact
- Understated, poetic text with effective use of repetition (phrases like 'it goes like this') creates a timeless, rhythmic quality
- Successfully portrays working-class life and coal mining heritage with dignity and without judgment
- The chilling final lines about the boy's inevitable future as a miner resonate deeply with adult readers
- Effective at generating empathy and gratitude in readers for their own circumstances
- Strong father-son relationship depicted through subtle details and the boy's constant awareness of his father's dangerous work
Common critiques
- The 1950s time period is not clearly indicated in the illustrations, causing confusion until readers reach the author's note
- Children often miss the darker themes entirely, focusing on surface details rather than the social commentary
- Some reviewers feel the text is too understated and could have been more emotionally impactful or deeper
- The spacious kitchen illustration seems inconsistent with depicting a poor mining family
- The inevitability of the boy's future as a miner can feel depressing rather than uplifting to some readers
Reviews
There are no reviews yet.